RECORD: Darwin, C. R. Referee report of P. Smyth's manuscript "Observations on the Geology & Natural History of Teneriffe". (3.1858) RoySoc-RR3.255 Transcribed and edited by Kees Rookmaaker and John van Wyhe (Darwin Online,

REVISION HISTORY: Transcribed and edited by Kees Rookmaaker and John van Wyhe 12.2011. RN1

NOTE: The images are © The Royal Society and are reproduced with permission.


Down Bromley Kent

March 5. 1858

Dear Sir

Prof. Smyth's observations on the Geology & Natural History of Teneriffe do not appear to me precise enough, owing no doubt to the author's attention having been directed to other objects, for publication in the Philosophical Transactions. For instance in the remarks on "Craters of Elevation", masses of rock & subordinate craters are spoken of as of submarine origin, without any sort of evidence having been advanced: the continuity of not one single observ sheet of lava in the ancient cliffs of the great crater seems to have been noticed; the proportional width of the sec radial valleys to the whole crater is not noticed, &c.; and even the remarks on the subsided masses


on one side of the Taoro valley, — the most interesting case in the paper — are not given in sufficient detail for anyone, in my opinion, to judge whether they bear out the author's view that the whole width of the valley has subsided. Nor do the observations on the Vegetation appear to me sufficiently novel to deserve publication. I would suggest that the Author should be asked to draw up an abstract for the Proceedings of any points actually observed by him, rather than of the conclusions, which he has arrived at from, as far as it appears, hardly sufficient grounds. The supposed marks of ancient Glaciers should be noticed in any abstract,


in order to draw the attention of any future observers. An abstract might be given on the rate of growth of the Dragon-tree. —

Dear Sir
Yours faithfully
Ch. Darwin

To the Secretary, Royal Society

P.S The paper is returned by the same Post, which takes this.—


P. Smyth by Darwin

Smyth's paper was not published in the Transactions. See Correspondence vol. 7, letter 2234.

This document has been accessed 2042 times

Return to homepage

Citation: John van Wyhe, editor. 2002-. The Complete Work of Charles Darwin Online. (

File last updated 2 July, 2012