(1)

List

of

Reviews &c.

I. English

Page

Abernethy, Dr., and the grocer. 152

Agassiz, Prof. Louis. Lecture on "Public Museums" before the Mercantile Library Association, Jan. 1860. 4

"Agriculture in Massachussetts." The Congregationalist and Recorder. May 24, 1867. 32

"Amor Scientiae" on "Darwin and Huxley v. their critics." 156

Argyll, The Duke of, on Mr. Darwin's theory of development. 157

Aveling, Edward B., "Darwin and his work" Paper I, Student's Magazine and Science and Art, Sept. 2, 1878; Paper 2, Oct. 1, 1878. 169, 170

— On Worms. 106

Battle of Battles, The. Verses &c. 19-21

Beal, W.J. On Cross and self-fertilization of plants. 155

Belfast N.H & P. Soc. Address by J. J.

     do . . . . . .  On Orchids . . . . 87

Bill. B.B., "Something concerning the false philosophies that spread themselves abroad in our land." Tenby, Dec. 1880. 23

Bree. C.R., ,on the Origin of species. 10

— Species not transmutable. The Saturday Analyst and Leader, Nov. 10, 1860. 143

— do  The London Review. Dec. 29, 1860. 86

— Reply to Matthew Pattrick Matthews on his letter referring to the Review of Species not transmutable  144

(2)

Page

Brewster, Sir David. Inaugural Address at the Edinburgh University.  40

British Association discussion on the Origin of Species.   92

Butler, Samuel. ("Cellarius" and "Lunaticus") "Darwin among the machines". The Press, N.Z., June 13, 1863 and Sept. 15, 1863.    130, 133.

Cambrian Archaeological Assoc. at Shrewsbury, Aug. 2, 1881. . . . . . 57

"Cellarius" and "Lunaticus". See Butler, Samuel.

Conway, Moncure D., "Our fellow worms."    65

Crawfurd         on the Origin of Species.     50

Darwin's (The). Leisure House, Sept. 11, 1880. . . . . 73

Darwin. C.

— The Origin of Species, The coming of age of the." A lecture at the Royal Institution, March 19, 1880. By T.H. Huxley. Nature, May 5, 1880.    108

—  —    The British Association discussion. The Manchester Examiner, Sept 9/61.    92

— The Origin of Species. Reviews, &c.

Athenaeum. Nov. 19. 1859.     8

— Aug. 4, 1860.                      9

— Nov. 3, 1860. By C.R. Bree.   10

• Aug. 14, 1869. By J. Robertson.   14

Cambridge Chronicle, May 19, 1860. The Rede Lecture by Dr. John Phillips.   29

— "Prof. Sedgwick on Darwin's Theory' May 19, 1860.     29

Christian Union. Sept. 17, 1870. By Prof. E.L. Youmans. . 30

Critic (The), Nov. 30 1861. The Three Barriers: Notes… By G.R.      33

Daily News, Dec. 26, 1859.     37

—   Nov. 7, 1861. Sir David Brewster's inaugural address at the Edinburgh University.    40

Examinar. By Crawfurd.    50

Falkirk Herald, Feb. 16, 1860.   51

Free Sunday Advocate. Lecture by G.G. Zerffi    54 [CUL-DAR226.1.54-55]

(3)

Page

Darwin. C. The Origin of Species. Reviews &c.

Glasgow Free Press. Aug. 18, 1860.  59

Guardian. Oct. 13, 1869. . . 61

Lincoln, Notts. and North Midland Times, Dec. 13, 1859. 77

Literary Gazette, May 12, 1860. "The Universities—Cambridge, May 10"  79

London Review, July 14, 21, 1860. "The type-plans of animated beings and the speculations of philosophers"   83, 84

Mining and Commmercial Record, Apr. 25/60 Meeting of Dublin Geolog. Society   96

Morning Star, Dec. 15, 1859.   98

Nation. March 23, 1871.  101

Northern Daily Express, March 30, 1860.  116

Northern Whig, Nov. 19, 1860 . . . 118

Oracle, April 23, 1881.   123

Press, Dec. 20, 1862. A dialogue.   131

Reader, Dec. 1, 1866. Review of 4th. ed.   138

Record, Dec. 12, 1860.   139

Saturday Review (no date) Introducing the anecdote of Dr. Abernethy and the grocer.   152

— Dec. 24, 1859.   145

— May 5, 1860. . . . 146

Scotsman, Jan. 23, 1862. Darwin and Huxley v. their critics; a letter signed "Amor Scientiae".    156

— Jan. 18, 1862. Mr Huxley's fancies about man and apes. A letter signed "Scalpel".   156

— Dec. 4, 1866. By Dr. John Duns. . .  156

— Dec. 6, 1864. By the Duke of Argyll.   159

Spectator. March 24, 1860. Objections to Mr. Darwins theory. Replies to the Archbishop of Dublin's inquiry.   161

Times. Dec. 26, 1859. (In Box labelled Review Scraps.)

See Type-plans of animated beings &c.

(4)

Page

Darwin. C. Fertilisation of Orchids.

Athenaeum, May 24, 1862.   11

Literary Churchman, July 16, 1861.  78

London Review, June 14, 1862.  87

Nation, April 11, 1878.  102

Parthenon, June 7, 1862.  129

Register, August, 1862. By W.B. Tegetmeier   140

Saturday Review, Oct. 18, 1862.  147

— The power of movement in Plants:

Aberdeen Daily Free Press. (no date).   1

Academy. Feb. 12, 1881. By G. Henslow. 3

American Journal of Science. Jan., 1881, By Asa Gray.  6

Athenaeum. Dec. 18, 1880.  15

Edinburgh Daily Review. 1881.   49

Examiner. Nov. 27, 1880.  51

Gardeners' Chronicle. Nov. 27, 1880.   56

Glasgow Herald. Nov. 1880.  60

John Bull (no date)  67

Manchester Guardian. March 9.  1881.  93

Midland Counties Herald (no date)  96

Nation. Jan. 5, 1881.   105

Pall Mall Gazette. Nov. 26, 1880.  127

Pharmeceutical Journal and Transactions, Dec. 11, 1880.  130

St. James's Gazette. (no date)

—  Dec. 7, 1880.    141

Saturday Review, Jan. 8, 1881.   151

Science, March, 1881.   154

Scotsman, Dec. (?  159

Spectator, Jan. 8, 1881.   165

Standard, Nov. 25, 1880.   167

Times, Nov. 20, 1880.  171

Westminster Review  (no date)  176

(5)

Page

 Darwin. C. Variation of Animals and Plants under Domestication:

Orange Judd & Co's prospectus slip of the American edition.   68

British Association Address. By Rev. M.J. Berkeley.   27

Athenaeum, Feb. 13, 1868.  13

    do — — Reply to Dr. Hooker. Aug. 29, 1868.   14

Boston Investigator. March 2, 1870, By "Eboracum".   25

Daily Telegraph. Feb. 20, 1868.   43

Field. April 18, 1868.   52

Imperial Review. Feb. 22, and May 7, 1868.   88-90

Manchester Guardian. Apr. 8/68.  94

Nation March 19, 1868.   99

— The effects of N.Y. Evening Post. 1868   113

Pall Mall Gazette. Feb. 10, 15 and 17, 1868.   124-127

Saturday Review, March 14 and 28, 1868. 148-150

Spectator. March 14, 1868.  163

— The effects of cross and self-fertilisation: Nation, Apr. 11/78   102

Scientific Farmer, June, 1877.   155

— Different forms of flowers:
Nation, April 11, 1878.   102

— Worms:
Worm-work. A review in rhyme. Signed K. Dec. 20, 1881.   69

(6)

Page

Darwin. C. Worms:

Banffshire Journal, Oct. 18, 1881.   17

Bazaar, Nov. 2, 1881.   21

Belgian News and Continental Advertiser, Dec. 3, 1881.   22

Bookbuyer, Nov. 1, 1881.   24

Boy's Newspaper, Nov. 9, 1881.    26

Christian World. (no date)   31

Critic. Jan. 14, 1882.  35

Daily Free Press. Oct. 19, 1881.   36

Daily Review. Oct. 12, 1881.   42

Daily Telegraph, Oct. 18, 1881.   44

English Churchman and Clerical Journal. Dec. 1, 1881.   49

Field. Oct. 29, 1881.   53

Jouranl of Forestry, Dec. 1881.   68

Gardeners' Chronicle. Cot. 15, 1881.  58

Glasgow Herald, Oct. 11, 1881.   61

Guardian. Nov. 2, 1881.   63

Hibernia, Jan. 2, 1882.   64

Index, Dec. 22, 1881. By Moncure D. Conway.  65

Inverness Norther Chronicle, Dec. 14, 1881. 71

Land, Nov. 26, 1881.   72

Land and water, Dec. 3, 1881.   72

Literary World, Oct. 21, 1881, and Dec. 17, 1881.   91

Mace, Nov. 1, 1881.  91

Morning Post. Dec. 23, 1881.  97

National Reformer, Oct. 30, 1881. By Edward B. Aveling, D.Sc.  106

(7)

Page

Darwin. C. Worms:

Nature, Oct 13, 1881. By G.J. Romanes.   111

North British Agriculturalist. Nov. 2, 1881.  115

North British Daily Mail.   1881.  115

Pall Mall Gazette, Oct. 17, 1881.   152

St. James's Gazette, Oct. 17, 1881.    152

Scotsman, Oct. 29, 1881.  160

Spectator, Oct. 22, 1881.   166

Standard, Oct. 15, 1881.   168

Times, Oct. 10, 1881.   172

Wstern Daily Mercury, Plymouth, Oct. 1881.   175

Yorkshire Post and Leeds Intelligencer  By H.F. Moore, Oct 25 (?   176

Darwin. C. The Copley Medal. Royal Soc. Anniv.,
1864. The Reader, Dec. 3, 1864.   134

— The Oxford honorary degree,
The Daily News, June 20, 1870   40

— An excursion to Down of the members of the Lewisham & Blackheath Scientific Assoc. July 10, 1880. Proceedings, 1880.    77

— Address from the Council of the Otago Institute, N.Z., Oct. 1, 1880.
Nature, Feb. 24, 1881.    110

— "Homage to Mr. Darwin"— Yorkshire Naturalists Union deputation. Nature, Nov. 18, 1880.   110

— Presentation of the memorial. The Naturalist: Journal of the Yorkshire Naturalists' Union

— Letter on Child-life to Mrs Emily Talbot, Boston, Mass. Journal of Education. Sept. 8, 1881.

— and Steudel's Nomenclator. Nature, Jan. 5/82    113

(8)

Page

 

Darwin. C. On The mural tablet erected in Highstreet Free Christian Church, Shrewsbury, to the memory of C.R. Darwin …. 44 [CUL-DAR226.2.44[.3]]

"Darwin among the machines" Signed "Cellarius"…. 130 [Samuel Butler]

"Darwin's Hypothesis" Reply to Dr. Hooker's comments on the Athenaeum critiques. Athenaeum, Aug. 29, 1868.   14

"Darwin on Species". Verse. 3rd ed. spp. 8vo.   46

"Mr. Darwin at the Antipodes" Spectator, Apr. 6/67.   162

       do Australasian, July 13, 1867.      16

Darwinian theory. Examination Papers. Natural Sciences Tripos. March 6, 1860. Geology.     47

"Darwin and Huxley v. their critics" By "Amor Scientiae"    156

Darwin. C. R. The mural tablet erected to the memory of.    44

Darwin, Erasmus. Arbitrary Notice. Daily News, Aug. 30, 1881.   41

Darwin, G. st. On the geological importance of the tides. Jan. 5, 1882.

Dublin, Archbp, of. Replies to the inquiry of the Dublin Geological Soc. Meeting, Apr. 25, 1860.   96

Duns,  Dr. John. "The unity and antiquity of the human race". Lecture at Edinburgh, The Scotsman. Dec. 4, 1866.   156

"Eboracum" Evolution "Epigenesis or Evolution?"    24

      do On variation of Animals & Plants.    25

Evolution By "Eboracum" Boston Investigator      24

      do  The theory explained. The Oracle, April 30, 1881.     123

Examination Paper. Natural Science Tripos, Mar. 6, 1860     47

Flint. C.L. Review of his Report to the Massachussetts Ba. of Agricult. 1860    32

Gray, Asa. On movement in Plants. 6

* Haughton Prof.

Henslow, George. On movement in Plants.   3

Hooker,   Reply to Dr. Hooker's comments on the Athenaeum critiques.    14

* Haughton, Prof. "Comparison of modern theories of the origin of Species". Geolog. Soc. Dub. April, 1860    96

(9)

Page

Hutton. R.H. (one of the Editors of the Spectator)
"Phases of unbelief and how to meet them"; read at the Liverpool Church Congress, Oct. 5, 1869. The Guardian, Oct. 13, 1869.     61

"Huxley's (Mr) fancies about man and apes," By "Scalpel".     156

— "The coming of age of the Origin of Species"     108

Jeffreys, Gynn. Article against Evolution. The Watford Observer. Feb. 28, 1880.    173

Judd & Co's prospectus slip of the American edition of Variation of Animals and Plants.    68

K. Worm-worms. verses . . . . . .  69

Kerr. J. Worm-work. Verses.    69

"Lunaticus" See Butler. S.

Lewisham & Blackheath Scientific Assoc.:
Visit of the members to Down.      77

MacIlwaine v. J.J. Murphy and the origin. . . . 120

Matthew, Patrick, Reply to, on his letter referring to the review of Dr. Bree's Species not transmutable, &c. The Saturday Analyst and Leader. Nov. 24/60    144

Moore. H.F. On worms.    176

Murphy. Joseph J. "Some present aspects of science." The Northern Whig, Belfast, Nov. 19, 1866; and letter concerning this.   118, 119

Murray. Review of Geographical Distribution of Mammals. The Reader. July 21/66.    136

O'Callaghan, Edward Hackett. A word on Darwin and the advanced thinkers. Bassett's Chronicle. March 22, 1882.    18

O'Neill, T. Warren. The Refutation of Darwinism. Literary World. Mar. 27, 1880.    79

—   do The Nation Mar. 4, 1880    104

Otago Inst., N.Z. Address.     110

Owen, Richard. Palaeontology. Saturday Review May 5, 1860.    146

Phases of unbelief, and how to meet them. Discussion at St. George's Hall, Oct. 5, 1869     61

(10)

Page

Phillips, John. Rede Lecture at Cambridge.     29

R.G. "The three barriers.    33

Robertson. John. On the Origin of Species.    14

Romanes, Geroge J., On Worms.      111

"Scalpel". Mr. Huxley's fancies about man and apes.     156

Sedgwick, Prof. Adam. On the Origin of Species.   29, 161

Smith. W.G. "A holiday in Shropshire". Gardeners' Chronicle. Oct. 20, 1881.    57

Stanton, T. Quest-ce que le Darwinisme? Slendel's Nomenclator. p. 113

"Sword. J.G." The Battle of Battles. Verses &c. . . . . 19, 20, 21

Talbot, Mrs. Emily, A letter to, on child-life.    67

Tegetmeier, W.B., On the Fertilisation of Orchids.    140

Thomson, C. Wyville, and Natural Selection. A letter in Nature Nov. 18, 1880.    110

Tristram, Rev. H.B. Pres. Tyneside Nat. Field Club. On the Origin    116

Type-plans of animated beings and the speculations of philosophers- 2nd and concluding articles.    83, 84

"Universities, The".  Literary Gazette.   79

Worm-work. Verses. By K. . . . . 69

Yorkshire Naturalists' Union deputation.   106, 110

Youmans, Prof. E.L. "Mr. Darwin and his work."  Christian Union, N.Y., Sept. 17, 1870.   30

Zerffi, Dr. G.G. Lecture at the "Sunday evenings for the people" on "Darwinism in its influence on the times." Free Sunday Advocate, Jan. 1, 1877.    54

(11)

List of

Reviews &c.

II. Foreign

Page

Boscowitz, Arnold. On the French translation of the Origin of Species.  274

Bronn and Carus. The German edition of the Origin of Species.   251-

"Courte observation"    221

Darwin. C. Origin of Species:

Das Ausland. 22 Jan, 1867.    196

    do   5 März, 1860       200

Deutsche landwirtsch. Zeitung, Nov. 7, Nov. 9 and 11, 1876. Von Emil Du Bois Reymond.    222

Kölner Zeitung. 18, 21, 22, 23, 25 Juli, 1868— German ed. by Bronn and Carus.    251-257

Neue Stettiner Zeitung. 20 Sept. 1863 Von Haeckel.    273

Presse (la). 28 Mars, 1864. André Sanson.    262

Temps (Le). 17 Juillet, 1864. Review of the French translation by Mlle Clémence-Auguste Royer. Signed Arnold Boscowitz.   274

— Fertilisation of Orchids:

Das Ausland. 1865, Nos 13 & 14     190, 193

— The power of movement in Plants:

Die Gartenlaube. No. 14, 1881. By Carus Sterne (Ernst Krause) part only    229

(12)

Page

Darwin. C. The power of movement in Plants:

Die Gartenlaube . . . . .  229

Die Gegenwart. 9 Juli, 1881 By Carus Sterne (Ernst Krause)  233

— — Wiener allgemeiner Zeitung, 5 Dec. 1880. Signed G. M     282

— Variation of Animals and Plants under Domestication:          200

Allgemeine Zeitung. 1 Aug., 1868.    187

Das Ausland. 1868. 3 numbers.      200

     do ——— German edition . . . . 211

Magazine für die Literatur des Auslands. By Karl Russ.    249

— Worms:

Berliner Tageblatt. 10 Dec., 1881.     216

Deutsche landwirtsch. Zeitung Jan 31 and 1 April, 1882.      225

Die Gegenward. By Carus Sterne [Ernst Krause]      235

Y Goleuad. Hydref 15, 1881.    238

Illustrierte Zeitung. Dec. 3 & 10, 1881. By Otto Zacharias.    246

Leipziger Tageblatt und Anzeiger, 13 Dec., 1881. By Otto Zacharias.   248

Niederschlesischer Anzeiger, Glogan, 4 and 6 Dec., 1881. By Otto Zacharias.   260

Die Presse, Wien, 9 Nov., 1881. By H.Z.   262

Revue Scientifique. 21 Janvier, 1882. Par Henry Gravez    265

St. Petersburger Zeitung 23 Nov. (5 Dezember) ? year.    272

Wiender allgemeine Zeitung. 16 Jan. '82     283

— On the character and hybrid-like nature of the offspring from the illegitimate unions of dimorphic and trimorphic plants. Botanische Zeitung, 2, 9, & 16 Oct., 1868. Von F. Hildebrand.    217

(13)

Page

"Darwin. C. est élu correspondant".

Bulletin des sociétés savants, 5 août '78    220

— do La Science pour tous 19 août, 1878 in la France.    226

— "Zu Darwin's Geburtstag" National Zeitung ? 11 Feb. ?    257

—  70 Geburtstag. Deutsche landwirtsch: Zeitung. 13 Feb. 1879     225

Darwin at Home. Oost en West. Haarlem. 5 Aug., 1880.    284

— Erasmus. Article by Otto Zacharias in Die Gegenwart March 11, 1882     237

—See Vivisection or Holmgren.    

Daryl, Philippe p. 279

Du Bois-Reymond "Darwin".    222

Das Gehirn Deutschlands. Allgemeine Zeitung, Stuttgart. 23 Oct., 1878.     188

Gravez. H. On Worms.    265

Haeckel.  On the Origin of Species.   273

Hegel über Darwin. Wiener allgemeine Zeitung, 17 Apr., 1881.     282

Hesse-Wartegg, Ernst v. "Bei Charles Darwin" Frankfurter Zeitung 30 July, 1880.     228

Hildebrand. F. Character &c. … of the offspring…of dimorphic and trimorphic plants. Botanische Zeitung. Oct., 1868.    217

Holmgren, Prof., "Une lettre de M. Ch. Darwin  sur la vivisection" à M. le Professeur Holmgren, d'Upsal. Revue Scientifique. 4 Juin, 1881.    264

Krause, Ernst. See Carus Sterne.

M.(G.) On the power of movement in plants     282

— Worms.  . . . . . . .  283

Mengozzi, Prof. G.E. Critica di Darwin del Filopanti. Roma Etrusca, Roma. 15 Luglio, 1881.  271

R. (Dr. B). On the Origin of species . . . . . 251

Royer, Mlle Clémence-Auguste, French translation of the Origin of species     274

(14)

Page

Russ, Karl. On Variation of Animals and Plants under Domestication.    249

Russian Newspaper. HOBOE BPEMA. 1878.       243 [Moskovski fyelieto]

Sanson, André. On the Origin of species.    262

Stanton, Theodore. Quest-ce que le Darwinisme? Résumé d'une conférence de Monsieur Leblois, 5 Avvil, 1881. Strasbourg. The Free Religious Index. Aug. 11, 1881.     53

Sterne, Carus: On The power of movement in plants.     229

Worms.       235

La vie littéraire en Angleterre. V. Las savants et les petes. Le Temps. 31 août, 1881   279

Vignes, E., "Le nouveau membre correspondant d l'institut:. La France, 19 août, 1878.    226

— "Les architectes de la mer. D'apres de livre de Ch. Darwin" La France. 26 août ? year.    227

Vivisection.  "Une lettre de M. Ch. Darwin sur la vivisection" a M. le professeur Holingren, d'Upsal.    264

Vogt, Karl. Descendenz-Theory und Socialismus. Neue Freie Press, Wien 12 & 14 Dec., 1878.     258

— "Charles Darwin". Die Heimat, 1880.   

Z.(H) On Worms . . . . .  262

Zacharias, Otto. On Worms.  246, 248 260

— Life of Erasmus Darwin. Article in Die Gegenwart, March 11, 1882.    237