RECORD: Darwin, C. R. & Emma Darwin. 1841.06-07. Ch 3 (notes on Bees finding flowers). CUL-DAR46.2.C10-C11. Edited by John van Wyhe (Darwin Online, http://darwin-online.org.uk/)
REVISION HISTORY: Transcribed by Christine Chua and edited by John van Wyhe 8.2022. RN1
NOTE: See record in the Darwin Online manuscript catalogue, enter its Identifier here. Reproduced with permission of the Syndics of Cambridge University Library and William Huxley Darwin. The volume CUL-DAR46.2 contains Notes for Natural selection.
"Abberley, John, 1840-50. Gardener at The Mount. Sent CD observations on ants and bees. CD asked A to plant "single Peas, Kidney Bean & Bean, intertwined, without sticks" and observe. Questions & experiments notebook. DAR 206.11. CCD2." (Paul van Helvert & John van Wyhe, Darwin: A Companion, 2021.)
Bevan, Edward. 1838. The honey-bee; its natural history, physiology, and management. London. 2d ed. London.
[C10]
[later insertion in brown crayon:] Ch 3 (notes on Bees finding flowers)
Maer June 41.
Humbles certainly often visit same flower in Bunch twice— Peculiar kinds seem most attached to certain plants; thus a very large one to Larkspur & small black one to Fraxinella, though several other kinds frequent the latter— small & Domestic Bees the Thyme
I observe thrice Humbles flying in straight line from one Larkspur to a large conspicuous Larkspur, in wh. had not one blossom open & the buds not showing much colour— The second plant was about 15 yd distant— Hence not small; nor sight of flower of Bee Larkspur nor habit of going to that bush—, but aspect of general plant— I think most Bees seem to know the Flower garden, they do not very often, though they do often go examining (a)— I saw Humble Bees many times fly from Fraxinella
[C10v]
{The extraordinary degree in which lower petal of Mimulus, wings & keel of a red everlasting Pea are scratched & torn show how often large Bees visit same flower— X What thousands have I watched & this summer never seen them ever examine Heartease or I believe Phlox — yet some flowers a hunting bee they will examine
[C11]
to another plant by straightest line, round thick bush, which hid sight.— I have seen them fly suddenly & strangely from Pink to white Fraxinella.— Perhaps these Bees well knew garden.— shows sight not sole means of knowledge— Bees entering the close flowered Iris & Snap-dragon, not aboriginals, shows small & acquired knowledge— I have seen at Shrewsbury go straight from one Linaria to another which was hidden by a Phlox.—I see Bevan doubts much eye sight to Bees.— from 12 to 2000 in Hive besides drones— go from 3 to 5 miles = Bevan quotes many authorities to show that Bees visiting pollen, (chiefly in morning) keep to same species.— Mem Poppies — Mem Oenothera (a) will it be supposed at Maer where few gardens one Bee can be content with only this plant I have seen them go to the Poppies &c — As far as final cause is concerned, their visiting, when nectar-hunting different species, is equally hostile to such views —
[C11v]
[This page is in Emma Darwin's handwriting]
(a) This very day (Shrewsbury July 12/41) I saw several bees Humbles with large masses of pollen certainly collecting pollen on pink Didinam Mimulus rosea plant with forceps stigma Abberly says a Mimulus of which there was only 1 clump in garden & not probably any in Neighbourhood. N.B at same time many nectar hunting bees visited flower & it was beautiful to see how lower division stigma licked back of the bee X & hairy anthers dusted it. I can't see use of brush of papillae & difft colour of lower side of tube of corolla, in this flower with yellow Mimulus in foxglove & many other didinams.
Citation: John van Wyhe, ed. 2002-. The Complete Work of Charles Darwin Online. (http://darwin-online.org.uk/)
File last updated 28 August, 2023